Nestor Gambino doesn’t smoke. He’s always hated the taste of tobacco.
“I think maybe my whole life I’ve smoked two cigarettes,” he said.
But the Sunnyside convenience store owner is worried about the state’s latest expected tax increase on tobacco. Cigarette sales make up at least 20 percent of business at the Buena Vista Market, which he owns with his two brothers.
Customers complain and say they’re quitting for sure this time, said Gambino, adding some will succeed, some only try.
To help plug a $2.8 billion budget hole, state legislators earlier this month passed a wide range of tax increases on mass-produced beer, soda, bottled water and a variety of tobacco products. If Gov. Chris Gregoire signs the bills, as expected, the taxes will take effect in 10 days.
The taxes on cigarettes alone will jump $1 to $3.03 per pack. That will take the average cost of a pack of smokes to $7.30, said Mike Gowrylow, a state Department of Revenue spokesman.
The increase will give Washington the second-highest cigarette taxes in the nation behind Rhode Island and more than twice the national average of $1.40 per pack, according to the Campaign for Tobacco Free Kids.
The hikes come on the heels of a 62-cent increase in cigarette taxes imposed by the federal government last year. The federal tax is now $1.01 per pack. Washington bumped up its taxes by 60 cents per pack in both 2001 and 2005.
Gambino’s right. Some smokers will quit simply because their habit is getting too expensive.
Tobacco Free Kids says on its Web site that every 10 percent increase in the price of cigarettes leads to a 4 percent decrease in smoking. Washington’s jump will spur 19,200 smokers to quit, the group says.
Financial forecasters at the Revenue Department predict even more quitters. They figure every 10 percent increase in the price of cigarettes leads to a 10 percent drop in consumption, Gowrylow said.
True, some of those who try to quit might go back, said Donn Moyer, a spokesman for the state Department of Health. But it takes an average of eight tries to successfully stop, he said.
“If that’s one of the eight … so be it,” he said. “That’s a good thing.”
Smokers, however, feel picked on and accuse the state of preying on their addiction to balance the books.
“Every time you turn around, someone, somewhere is kicking you in the teeth,” said Doug Pacheos, a 55-year-old smoker and owner of a downtown Sunnyside bar. (He also opposed the beer tax increase.)
Pacheos takes a cynical view of the state’s motives.
“Cigarette smoking is bad except for the revenue part of it,” he said.
The idea that the state’s new tax could drive smokers to tribal smoke shops is misguided, said Brenda Fisher, national sales manager for Lil’ Brown Smoke Shack on the Yakama reservation. Though shops like Lil’ Brown don’t charge the state tax, they still are required to collect federal tobacco taxes. So the difference isn’t that great, Fisher said.
“People shop where they shop,” she said. “A lot of it is convenience, and it’s a hike to get out here to the reservation.”
It’s possible recent increases in both federal and state tobacco taxes will lead people to quit, which isn’t good for anybody in the industry, Fisher said.
“There’s been such an attack on the tobacco industry in general, the small segment of the population that still smokes seems to be shouldering the burden,” she said.
The state tax increase comes at the same time as a 17 percent, or $2.65 million, reduction in the state’s tobacco prevention and control program funding.
In the past two years, the program has lost $14 million to budget cuts — a 54 percent decrease. Those cuts caused the state to terminate its mass media advertising campaign. It also prompted cutbacks in the services provided under the state Health Department’s Tobacco Quit Line. For example, callers get four weeks of nicotine replacement material, such as gum or patches, instead of eight.
While smoking cessation advocates laud the tax increases, they liken it to fighting a battle on only one front.
“We believe strongly that when you increase tobacco taxes, the resources need to be there to help people quit,” said Erin Dziedzic, a spokeswoman for the Action Network, a lobbying arm of the American Cancer Society.
Gordon Kelly, environmental health director of the Yakima Health District, said he typically sees a temporary decrease in smoking after a tax increase, but many smokers come back. He also suspects more people will just drive across state lines to stock up on quantities of cigarettes.
That’s illegal with any sized load, punishable by a fine of up to $10 a pack or $250, whichever is greater.
Still, Yakima County is headed in the “appropriate” direction when it comes to smoking, Kelly said.
In the county, 14.1 percent reported smoking cigarettes at the end of 2008, the most recent figures on the state Health Department’s website. That’s down from 18.8 percent in 2004 and lower than the state average of 15.3 percent.
Tony Bertsch, 50, has tried to quit before. Three days is the longest he has made it. He grew up on a farm in a shop where everybody around him smoked.
The Sunnyside resident owns a glass tinting business in Grandview.
Bertsch called the extra taxes unfair. So was Initiative 901, the 2005 voter-approved measure that banned smoking in public places, he said.
“You start feeling like a secondhand citizen,” he said.
Bob Guy, 55, said he has quit, though it took him five tries. His last cigarette was in November.
Still, the Outlook resident called the higher taxes unfair after picking up a pack of Marlboro Lights from Buena Vista Market for his daughter.
“Every time a new tax is needed, the government just nails the smokers,” he said.